Formerly Sears Home Warranty, Cinch pays for rust, corrosion, and unknown pre-existing conditions most competitors exclude — but its coverage caps are among the lowest in the industry.

---

If the name Cinch Home Services doesn’t immediately ring a bell, its previous identity might: the company operated for decades as Sears Home Warranty before rebranding, and it carries that legacy into 2026 with more than 45 years in business and a reported $1 billion-plus paid out in claims over its history. That long track record comes with a genuinely unusual mix of strengths and weaknesses — Cinch covers some things most competitors flatly exclude, while capping payouts on the items homeowners care about most more tightly than almost anyone else in the industry.

Quick Facts

Founded	1978 (formerly Sears Home Warranty)
Availability	47 states
Plans	Appliances Plan, Built-In Systems Plan, Complete Home Plan
Monthly premium	~$28 – $94, depending on plan and location
Service fee	$100 – $150 per visit
HVAC coverage cap	$1,500 per claim — below the industry standard of $2,000+
Plumbing coverage cap	$1,000 per claim
Appliance coverage cap	$1,000 – $2,000 per item, depending on plan
Aggregate annual limit	$10,000 across all plans — notably lower than several major competitors
Workmanship guarantee	180 days — roughly 6x the ~30-day industry standard
BBB rating	B to B+ (varies by source), with 2,400–3,145 complaints logged over the past 3 years
Trustpilot / ConsumerAffairs	~3.5/5 and ~4.25/5 respectively

Plans Explained

Appliances Plan

Covers major kitchen and laundry appliances — refrigerator, oven, dishwasher, washer, dryer, and similar. No systems coverage (HVAC, plumbing, electrical) included.

Built-In Systems Plan

Covers 16 systems and related components, including HVAC, plumbing, electrical, ductwork, and water heaters. No appliance coverage included.

Complete Home Plan

Combines both of the above into a single plan covering roughly 26 systems and appliances total. This is the plan most Cinch customers choose, and it includes one genuinely rare perk: a reimbursement of up to $500 toward your homeowners insurance deductible if you file a related insurance claim — a feature almost no other major provider offers.

What Makes Cinch Genuinely Different: Rust, Corrosion, and Pre-Existing Conditions

Most home warranty contracts specifically exclude damage caused by rust, corrosion, or conditions that existed before coverage began — these are among the most common reasons claims get denied industry-wide (see Why Was My Home Warranty Claim Denied? Common Reasons). Cinch is unusual in explicitly covering rust, corrosion, and unknown pre-existing conditions, which can be a meaningful advantage for older homes where these issues are common and where other providers would likely deny the claim outright.

Coverage Caps: The Trade-Off You’re Making for That Extra Coverage

Here’s the catch: Cinch’s willingness to cover rust, corrosion, and unknown pre-existing conditions comes paired with some of the lowest coverage caps in the industry. HVAC claims are capped at $1,500 — well below the $2,000–$5,000+ range common among major competitors like American Home Shield or Old Republic. Plumbing repairs cap at $1,000 per claim, and appliance coverage ranges from $1,000 to $2,000 per item depending on plan tier.

On top of the per-item caps, Cinch applies an annual aggregate limit of $10,000 across all claims combined — a real constraint compared to American Home Shield’s $50,000 aggregate, and worth factoring in if you expect multiple significant claims in a single contract year. On the base Appliances/Built-In Systems tiers, some items are also covered on a “per-instance” basis (paying up to $1,000 at a time for repeated issues with the same item) rather than a single lifetime-of-contract cap — a structure that can work in your favor for recurring smaller issues but adds complexity to understanding your total protection.

Bottom line on caps: if your HVAC system is aging and a full replacement is a real possibility, Cinch’s $1,500 cap will likely leave a substantial gap versus a $4,500–$8,000 replacement cost. If you’re mainly worried about smaller, recurring repair issues — especially on an older home where rust or pre-existing wear might get other providers to deny a claim — Cinch’s broader inclusion policy can offset the lower caps in practice.

Pricing

Plan example	Approximate Monthly Price
Repair + Replace plan	~$54.99
Repair + Replace Premier plan	~$77.99
Published range across all plans/states	~$28 – $94

Service fees run $100–$150 per visit, on the higher end compared to competitors like Select Home Warranty ($60–$75) or AHS’s lower tiers ($75). Cinch also advertises one of the faster response windows in the industry, with repairs typically scheduled within 2 to 24 hours of an accepted claim — faster than the roughly 48-hour average some competitors report.

Note that Cinch offers a different plan structure in California due to state-specific regulatory requirements, so pricing and coverage details for California residents should be confirmed directly rather than assumed from national averages.

What Customers Actually Say

Cinch holds a B to B+ BBB rating depending on the source, with somewhere between roughly 2,400 and 3,100 complaints logged over the past three years — meaningfully lower in raw volume than a giant like AHS, though Cinch is also a smaller operation. Common complaint themes mirror the rest of the industry: service delays, contractor quality inconsistency, and disputes over refunds for replaced items. On the positive side, Cinch is reported to actively respond to and resolve BBB complaints rather than ignoring them, and third-party review sites like ConsumerAffairs show a notably higher average score (around 4.25/5) than Trustpilot (around 3.5/5) — worth keeping in mind since review distributions can vary a lot by platform.

Pros and Cons

Pros	Cons
Covers rust, corrosion, and unknown pre-existing conditions — rare in this industry	HVAC cap of $1,500 is among the lowest of any major provider
180-day workmanship guarantee, 6x the industry standard	$10,000 aggregate annual limit is lower than several competitors
Fast advertised response window (2–24 hours)	Service fees run higher than several competitors ($100–$150)
Rare $500 reimbursement toward your homeowners insurance deductible	Different plan structure in California requires separate confirmation
Long operating history (45+ years, formerly Sears Home Warranty)	Coverage cap structure (per-instance vs. per-term) can be confusing to compare against competitors

Who Cinch Home Services Is Best For

• Owners of older homes where rust, corrosion, or unknown pre-existing conditions are a real risk that other providers would likely deny
• Homeowners who value a long workmanship guarantee and fast dispatch times over the highest possible coverage cap
• Buyers who want the rare insurance deductible reimbursement perk on the Complete Home Plan

Who Should Consider a Different Provider

• Homeowners with an aging HVAC system where a full replacement is a real possibility — the $1,500 cap is a significant limitation here compared to AHS’s $5,000 or Old Republic’s $6,500
• Anyone planning to file multiple large claims in a single year, given the relatively low $10,000 aggregate limit
• Buyers prioritizing the lowest possible service fee, since Cinch’s $100–$150 range runs higher than several budget-tier competitors

The Verdict

Cinch Home Services occupies a genuinely distinct niche in this comparison set: it’s more inclusive than most competitors on what it will cover (rust, corrosion, pre-existing conditions), backed by a long operating history and an unusually strong workmanship guarantee — but it caps how much it will pay out more tightly than almost any other major provider, especially on HVAC. For an older home where claim denials over rust or pre-existing wear are a realistic risk with other companies, that trade-off can genuinely work in your favor. For a home where a full HVAC replacement is the main risk you’re trying to insure against, the low cap makes Cinch a weaker fit than American Home Shield or Old Republic Home Protection.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Cinch Home Services the same as Sears Home Warranty? Yes — Cinch Home Services is the rebranded continuation of what was previously marketed as Sears Home Warranty, carrying over the same underlying operating history.

Does Cinch cover pre-existing conditions? Yes, notably including unknown pre-existing conditions and rust/corrosion damage, which most competitors explicitly exclude. This is one of Cinch’s clearest differentiators.

What is Cinch’s HVAC coverage cap? $1,500 per claim, which is below the $2,000–$5,000+ range common among major competitors — a significant factor if you’re relying on the warranty for a potential full system replacement.

How fast does Cinch respond to claims? Cinch advertises scheduling repairs within 2 to 24 hours of an accepted claim, generally faster than the roughly 48-hour average some competitors report.

Is Cinch available in California? Yes, but with a different plan structure and pricing due to state-specific regulatory requirements — confirm California-specific details directly with Cinch rather than relying on national averages.

What’s the aggregate coverage limit on a Cinch plan? $10,000 per contract year across all claims combined, lower than some major competitors like American Home Shield’s $50,000 aggregate limit.

---

Related reading: Best Home Warranty Companies of 2026 (Ranked & Reviewed) · American Home Shield vs Choice Home Warranty: Which Is Better? · Does a Home Warranty Cover HVAC Systems?

Information in this review reflects publicly available pricing, coverage, and reputation data as of mid-2026, sourced from Cinch Home Services’ public plan documentation and third-party review platforms including the BBB, Trustpilot, and ConsumerAffairs. Ratings, complaint volumes, and pricing change over time — always verify current details directly with the provider before purchasing.