Liberty Home Guard has some of the best customer review scores in the industry — but its BBB rating was revoked in 2024. Here’s the full breakdown. Liberty Home Guard shows up on almost every “best home warranty” list for one clear reason: its third-party review scores are consistently among the highest in the industry,…

Backed by a Fortune 500 parent company since 1984, First American offers uncapped coverage on several systems — but plan availability and pricing vary more than most competitors. First American Home Warranty (FAHW) has one advantage most competitors in this category can’t claim: it’s a subsidiary of First American Financial Corporation. A Fortune 500 company…

Formerly Sears Home Warranty, Cinch pays for rust, corrosion, and unknown pre-existing conditions most competitors exclude — but its coverage caps are among the lowest in the industry. If the name Cinch Home Services doesn’t immediately ring a bell, its previous identity might: the company operated for decades as Sears Home Warranty before rebranding, and…

Choice Home Warranty is one of the cheapest major providers — but a $3,000 combined HVAC cap and a 2026 Arizona settlement are worth knowing before you sign up. Choice Home Warranty (CHW) has built its position in the industry around a simple pitch: two straightforward plans, a flat service fee, and one of the…

An honest look at American Home Shield’s three plans, real pricing, coverage caps, and what customers actually complain about, based on 2026 BBB and Trustpilot data. American Home Shield (AHS) is the oldest and largest name in the home warranty industry — founded in 1971, with more than 2 million active members and availability in…

We compared pricing, HVAC coverage caps, BBB ratings, and complaint history across the top home warranty companies in the U.S. to find the best options for 2026. The home warranty industry has a marketing problem: almost every comparison site shows the same three numbers — monthly price, a star rating, and a BBB letter grade…